The Turbanator wrote:^ Looks like we have a winner



My bad, obviously I 'lose' if I don't reply for a few days.
The Turbanator wrote:^ Looks like we have a winner
Yep, totally.RedAppleGP wrote:Well will you respond
It's not 'one or two cases' of unjustified police force; it's the statistics that show blacks are disproportionately investigated for the same crimes as white people while they use them at the same rates.knot wrote:The statistical evidence for their claims is paper-thin. You can't just take 1 or 2 cases of unjustified police force against blacks and claim that there is institutionalized racism.
If black lives actually mattered to BLM, they should acknowledge that they have a huge cultural problem. Black people are massively overrepresented in the crime statistics, and especially in the more violent categories.
https://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/c ... verviewpdf
Their movement has nothing to do with saving black lives, and everything to do with getting attention and money for free while avoiding any responsibility
Even if that's true we can barely conclude anything at all from that fact. There are many possible explanations, and the police being racists seems to me one of the least plausible ones. If anything, they probably hate the fact that they catch more blacks than whites for drug possession. Potentially having your life ruined by the social justice mob doesn't seem very desirableIt's not 'one or two cases' of unjustified police force; it's the statistics that show blacks are disproportionately investigated for the same crimes as white people while they use them at the same rates.
Poverty plays some role, but culture is much more important, because people of different cultures react very differently to poverty. Some cultures will feel sorry for themselves, some will resort to crime and others will just work their ass off to try and improve their situation. For example, Chinese people and Jews show very high social mobility, and are good at overcoming initial poverty. On the other hand, blacks and Muslims have bad cultures (currently, as cultures aren't static) that tend to produce total losers. Both reject the "white" culture of education, and both are ruled by social pressure that's in place to make sure everyone within that culture stays an underachiever. Another central aspect to these two cultures is the perpetual state of victimhood. People who buy into the idea that they're the victims of invisble bigotry will naturally never try to achieve anything in life, but will instead feel justified in resorting to petty crime or to blowing themselves up. In this regard the democrats have done a lot of damage by constantly race-baiting and keeping black people fixed in a victim narrative.Some people argue that poverty plays a role, and I think that it probably does
Why is that, when racism is prevalent in the US?knot wrote:Even if that's true we can barely conclude anything at all from that fact. There are many possible explanations, and the police being racists seems to me one of the least plausible ones.
It's hard for me to reconcile with that that in NYC while people make up less than ten percent of people charged for marijuana related offenses.knot wrote:An explanation that seems much more likely to be true:
-Blacks are more likely to live in crime-ridden ghettos
-The police are more likely to patrol areas where crime is rampant
Therefore, blacks are more likely to get pulled over, searched and caught for relatively harmless crimes, like possession of weed. Even though weed usage is roughly equal for whites/blacks, this would explain why black people are charged for it more often, because there is a big disparity in the other crime categories.
...What the hell are you talking about?knot wrote:On the other hand, blacks and Muslims have bad cultures (currently, as cultures aren't static) that tend to produce total losers. Both reject the "white" culture of education, and both are ruled by social pressure that's in place to make sure everyone within that culture stays an underachiever.
Not exactly invisible when you're being shot.knot wrote:Another central aspect to these two cultures is the perpetual state of victimhood. People who buy into the idea that they're the victims of invisble bigotry will naturally never try to achieve anything in life, but will instead feel justified in resorting to petty crime or to blowing themselves up.
I see it the opposite- the democrats are doing tremendous help in acknowledging the racial component with these issues, and the republicans are doing harm in denying it.knot wrote:In this regard the democrats have done a lot of damage by constantly race-baiting and keeping black people fixed in a victim narrative.
This was well said, and in my experience seems to be the case. Particularly the case of rejection of education as being "white"; it's a big problem for black students, who are ridiculed by their peers for "acting white" when they study hard and do well in school. Unfortunately, all I have are anecdotes and personal experience.knot wrote: Poverty plays some role, but culture is much more important, because people of different cultures react very differently to poverty. Some cultures will feel sorry for themselves, some will resort to crime and others will just work their ass off to try and improve their situation. For example, Chinese people and Jews show very high social mobility, and are good at overcoming initial poverty. On the other hand, blacks and Muslims have bad cultures (currently, as cultures aren't static) that tend to produce total losers. Both reject the "white" culture of education, and both are ruled by social pressure that's in place to make sure everyone within that culture stays an underachiever. Another central aspect to these two cultures is the perpetual state of victimhood. People who buy into the idea that they're the victims of invisble bigotry will naturally never try to achieve anything in life, but will instead feel justified in resorting to petty crime or to blowing themselves up. In this regard the democrats have done a lot of damage by constantly race-baiting and keeping black people fixed in a victim narrative.
brimstoneSalad wrote:
This was well said, and in my experience seems to be the case. Particularly the case of rejection of education as being "white"; it's a big problem for black students, who are ridiculed by their peers for "acting white" when they study hard and do well in school. Unfortunately, all I have are anecdotes and personal experience.
It's very difficult to do any studies on the effect of culture on poverty, because the regressive left has already decided on its narrative of systematic oppression, and any attempt to study anything else will either have great difficulty getting funded, or even result in expulsion from the university thanks to social justice warriors attacking people's careers for saying things they don't agree with.
Academics in the "social sciences" is brutal, and ruled by the iron fist of the regressive leftists. It is not a place for legitimate science or learning, or questioning and having new ideas.
This is probably an issue that, due to resistance to even learning about it or discussing it, can not be solved.
Any attempt at bringing these things up will be drowned out by accusation of racism.
So, it's a shame to say that the best advice I can give is to ignore it, and stop trying to fix the problem and attempting to identify the real causes. Racist laws requiring more white people to be arrested to meet quotas will probably be passed at the culmination, then probably overturned by the courts, and that's probably as far as this will ever go.
It's a terrible thing that minorities will remain trapped in poverty and ignorance due to these factors, but since we can't fix it due to regressive leftist bullies, it's something that just has to be waited out. Maybe in a few generations things will even out a little?
Because the social and economic cost of being racist against blacks is huge nowadays in the US. If someone wants to act out their racist hate crime fantasies, the police force seems like the worst possible place to do so, especially given all the recent negative attention the police have gotten. If anything I expect they are probably scared shitless of having to deal with black criminals now.Why is that, when racism is prevalent in the US?
I don't see why that number is strange because it's not controlled for anything at all. For starters, how about controlling for poverty. In the other thread I posted a report that detailed how poor black people were more likely to handle the drugs out in the open. When you're selling and smoking pot out in the street, of course you're much more likely to get caught by the police.It's hard for me to reconcile with that that in NYC while people make up less than ten percent of people charged for marijuana related offenses.
I've noticed the same patterns between different minorities who do poorly: the blame for their own bad behavior or misfortune is always put on someone else. I don't know if the left started this idea, but they're certainly responsible for propagating it. Spreading the idea that black people are victims of some intangible racism is very damaging to their dignity and sense of agency, but this tactic is the bread and butter of movements like #BlackLivesMatter. The BLM people are narcissistic, opportunistic assholes who don't actually care about solving the real problems, but just want their 15 minutes of fame....What the hell are you talking about?
Seriously, where in the world are you getting this from?